• NME.COM
  • Saturday, 11 October 2008

NME News

Illegal downloaders to be threatened by UK ISPs

New agreement will see downloaders 'warned by letter'

Six major UK internet service providers (IPSs) have signed up to a new agreement to tackle illegal downloading in a move which will see hundreds of thousands of internet users sent warning letters about downloading music.

BT, Virgin, Orange, Tiscali, BSkyB and Carphone Warehouse have signed up to the agreement, which was negotiated by the government, reports BBC News.

The deal is called a Memorandum Of Understanding, and was drawn up by the Department For Business, Enterprise And Regulatory Reform (BERR).

The news comes in the same month that ISP Virgin Media sent around 800 warning letters to customers, saying their internet connections could be cut off if they continue to download music illegally.

However, the ISPs who have signed up to the new agreement have not agreed to threaten to cut off users' connections – something the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) wants them to do.

Geoff Taylor, chief executive of the BPI, said the move was a step closer to ISPs taking responsibility for dealing with illegal downloaders using their service.

The new agreement will apply to users who both upload and download music files.

"The focus is on people sharing files illegally," said [a]Taylor[/b]. "There is not an acceptable level of file-sharing. Musicians need to be paid like everyone else."

What do you think of this measure? Will it stop internet downloads? Is it an invasion of privacy? Are there alternatives that the music industry is ignoring or is it right that artists get to protect their music?

Have you say by posting below using MyNME.

Comments (13)

Add a comment

Tab-0la 

Jul 24, 2008

That's shit

crofty900 

Jul 24, 2008

good, about bloody time something was done about it, one : its not fair on artists. two: while im out earnin 10 pounds to go and buy a cd they go and do the lazy selfish thing and illegaly download it. its out of order

Sanderz666 

Jul 24, 2008

Once again the BPI thinks its best to aggressively go after people who download music rather than look at why people are downloading. They also consistently fail to realise that every other method for stopping illegal downloading has been over come and these new measures will be no exception. In fact there is already software available to encrypt information so that the ISP can't tell what type of information is being downloaded.

balzadelia 

Jul 24, 2008

i agree with crofty900 and only test listen to stuff im not sure about on sites like last fm/myspace. And theres nowt worse than people geting it for free after i save up to buy 1 cd and they just d/l a whole back catalogue it boils my piss so bring it on its about time .

Moosh2k7 

Jul 24, 2008

Downloading music boosts the music industry higher by fuckloads. End of.

andyc53 

Jul 24, 2008

I agree they should have testers like myspace etc and yes of course most people dowload the odd occasional track but heavy offenders should of course be pursecuted. I mean wake up and look at the facts. It's illegal therefore you don't have the right to do it anyway, you wouldn't steal a CD from a shop would you, yes it is the same thing! Secondly the artists deserve to be paid for their works. If you examine the facts and cultural trends also if people are forced to buy CDs they therefore will be most likely obtaining less music per anum thus they will have to make more careful selections of what music they chose to listen to consequently this will lead to a reaction from the artists and the industry whereby the quality of the music will have to be great in order for people to buy it.

2xtdg 

Jul 25, 2008

woooo now the music industry will fall on its ass hard and with no padding, awesome!i am poor and cant afford cds not saying i download but i know people that do, and the amount of shows i go to more than makes up for getting music from mates. and the fact i have 400+ cds anyway, buy all special editons and collectables?decrease the price of CD's and downloading will go away!xx

Apron Strings 

Jul 25, 2008

andyc53- " the industry whereby the quality of the music will have to be great in order for people to buy it."Do you not realise that if people downloaded more music, this would still be the case? More so, because a band can be shit, and noone would buy the album 'cause they would have already heard it via downloading. If everyone has heard every album (for speaking sake) then they'll know which album is worth buying and which isn't.

wastedlittledj92 

Jul 25, 2008

I know for a fact, that most bands dont see even a profit on their albums. I know people in the industry who have told me that illegal downloads are the way forward. Screw record labels and lets get back some independant music!!

ed2005 

Jul 28, 2008

In terms of things that the music industry should be focusing on, I think it would be far more worthwhile to try and clamp down on ticket touts (see the Tom Waits story on July 25). The notion of being monitored like this is far more ethically wrong than downloading music. End of story.

nedrauk 

Jul 31, 2008

I admit to downloading (sharing) in the napster days on DIALUP! It probably cost me way over £1.00 per track! I have though followed up "Thief" (appropriate?) by Our Lady Peace by ordering almost all their music on IMPORT!I might also ask why CD singles shoot up in price after the first week! No wonder sales are down!

ed2005 

Jul 31, 2008

Nedrauk - excellent point about the rising prices after the first week. It's reflective of the obsession of seeing hwo well things do immediately rather than over a period of time.

wezzers 

Sep 9, 2008

I am in complete agreement with 2xtdg. I am a student and simply cannot afford to buy all the albums, singles, special editions, greatest hits etc of all the artists which I like. I would much rather pay to see them perform live, which more than makes up for it anyway. I don't see why people should deprive themselves of music, good or bad, just because they simply cannot afford to purchase it. If illegal downloading wasn't around then I would not have heard of half the music of the majority of bands that I pay (more than once) to go see. And anyway, if I do have enough money then I will buy albums, I just can't afford to. What Duffy said about the kids not being able to afford music therefore this allows them to have greater access before they grow up and use their decent income to purchase music is completley true. Also, illegal downloading allows you to hear what's good and what's shit, usually resulting in the really good, deserved bands bing rewarded with album sales - which should hopefully let all the shit die out.

Add your comment

NME Alerts

Get NME news delivered direct to your desktop. Find out more

This Week's Issue
  • NME Magazine - The ultimate guide to the week in music
  • The ultimate guide to the week in music
  • NME Magazine - Subscribe now and save up to £37!
Please sign in

Forgot your password?

Register with MyNME

Every Tuesday and Friday

  • Up-to-the-minute news stories
  • The best new music and free downloads
  • Video interviews, photo galleries, competitions and more
  • Album and track reviews for the week ahead
  • Essential gigs in your area